Tankless Water Heaters
Review and Buying Guide
(updated 2019)

Tankless water heaters review and buying guide - pros and cons, benefits, top features, best brands, and models. What to look for and expect, to avoid potential problems and expensive troubleshooting.

When searching for the residential tankless water heaters, also called on-demand and instant hot water heaters, it is important to know that the tankless system and heating process is different from the tank-type systems. Use this article to explore how these high efficient and condensing products can benefit you, reduce the energy consumption and pollution and save you money.

There is a lot to read about tankless... so if you would like to know about the best models and check the reviews - read this article. If you would like to buy Rinnai, Noritz, Rheem, Navien, Stiebel Eltron, Eemax, Rheem or any other of the top models and are often on sale, check out the Amazon.com.

Highlights

• Top reasons to buy tankless
• Types
• How tankless works
• Video: Tankless basics
• Manufacturers
• Advantages and disadvantages

Top reasons to buy tankless

The main advantages of the best tankless water heaters are the tankless design that provides on-demand, continuous flow and an endless supply of hot water, low energy consumption (up to 50% reduction when comparing it to tank-type heaters), small and compact design, replaceable parts and condensing technology. This Rinnai model is a great example, as it offers quality elements resulting in superior efficiency, high performance, energy and emission reduction and most import - savings.

When comparing tankless technology with storage-tank, you will see that the conventional type is heating water even if there is no demand, while the tankless appliances work only when the hot water tap is open or on demand.

Tankless water heaters can use gas or electricity. The favorite type of the homeowners is the gas-powered with the electronic ignition, but you can also find models with the continuously burning pilot light, both types having pros and cons.

The size of the unit you need depends on demand, house and family size - check out the sizing guide. Some manufacturers offer a multi-system set-up that can link many units into one system, to satisfy the high demand of the large homes.

Majority of these tankless hot water heaters are the whole-house type, as they have a higher GPM flow rate, easy to handle high hot water demand, for more than one application at a time.

There are also some manufacturers that offer models not only for water heating but for space heating too, allowing, even more, options and savings for homeowners. These are known as the combi boilers, such as this Navien.

Type review

Electric-powered

Titan electric

Electric tankless hot water heaters have a compact and small design, allowing the wall and under the sink installation, saving you lots of space. They have a long service life as they are less prone to hard water and sediment deposits. There are two types to buy; point-of-use and whole-house. When compared to the gas type, electric tankless water heaters do not require venting and do not produce greenhouse gases.

Top 3 selling brands on Amazon.com are:

• EcoSmart ECO 27
  
• Stiebel Eltron Tempra 24
• Rheem RTE 13

Gas-powered

Bosch gas

Gas tankless hot water heaters are environmental friendly appliances also. Many of them utilize advanced technology for energy efficiency and meet strict emission standards. They can use natural gas or propane - LP. Gas tankless water heaters produce higher flow rates than the electric ones.

Tankless hot water heaters can be further divided into two categories; one that can only work as on/off (older models) and the other with the modulation (utilizing the modulating gas valve).

Hot water heaters with modulation, have the heat output depend on the water flow. For example; if the demand for hot water is higher, the modulating gas valve provides more gas, and the final result is more power.

The best of gas tankless models are those that utilize the condensing technology - where the "hidden" gas flue energy is used for preheating, and superior efficiency - Rinnai RUC98 is a great example - energy factor is ultra high, 0.96 and due to its ultra-low NOx emission is great on the environment.

Top 3 selling brands on Amazon.com are:

• Takagi T-KJr2
  
• Rinnai RL75iN
  
• Rheem RTGH-95DVLN
  

How tankless works

How tankless works (photo by Takagi)

After checking how tankless water heaters work, you will see that these models are more complex than standard cylinder type, so more knowledge and skills are required before trying to install or service them. This is especially true when dealing with the gas-powered units.

How electric tankless type works

Electric tankless heaters utilize the heating element that is controlled by the flow-sensing device that operates with a constant heat input and maximum flow rate. Flow rate depends on the pressure which can be adjusted on the knob.

If there is a request for the maximum flow, the outgoing water toward the hot water tap will be cooler since it spends less time passing through the heat exchanger.

How gas type works

Modern gas-powered tankless models use the latest technology where the output temperature, flow, safety, and other parameters are controlled and regulated by the electronic circuit board or small computer. Good examples are Rinnai, Noritz, Takagi or Paloma.

When you open the hot water tap a flow sensor in the tankless hot water heater sends the signal to the electronic module. From there signal goes to the gas valve to open the gas flow.

If all the requirements are met, natural gas or propane flows into the burner located inside the combustion chamber. The gas is ignited either by the pilot flame (older models) or spark from the electrode.

Burning gas heats the heat exchanger where the incoming cold water gets quickly heated to the pre-set and desired temperature. The heat exchanger transfers the heat from the burner to the water heating instantaneously. A vent pipe vents products of combustion out using the direct vent or powered vent system.

Once the faucet is turned off, the flow stops, and the flame goes out. As can be seen from the above explanation tankless water heaters heat the water on demand, while providing you with an endless supply of hot water. These models are mainly installed on the wall, saving the floor space for other use.

Video: Tankless basics

Manufacturers

Here is the list of the popular residential tankless hot water heaters in US and Canada, where many gas type units are Energy Star qualified, some brands are cheap while other, more advanced are expensive.

Gas-type

• Bosch
• Navien
• Noritz
• Paloma
• Rinnai
• Takagi

Electric-type

• EcoSmart
  
• Eemax
  
• Hubbell
  
• Titan
  

Advantages and benefits

• Endless hot water supply. Run out of water? Never.
• Durable, lifespan is 20 years or more (for some)
• You can save up to 50% of energy and heating costs
• High-efficiency heaters available, marked as Energy star
• Flexible installation options can be installed anywhere, inside or outside the house
• Lower greenhouse gas emissions
• Reliability rating is 99%
• Safety - no scalding injuries
• Provides you clean and fresh hot water
• No tank - no leaking problems
• Some models use smart technology with the self-diagnostic program (great for troubleshooting and repairs) and precise temperature control for enhanced safety and comfort
• Government tax credit, rebate and other incentives available to homeowners with the advanced, high efficient models
• Powered by natural gas or propane (LP)
• All the parts are replaceable

Disadvantages

• With the high up-front costs tankless system can cost up to three times as much as the tank-type heaters.
• Required upgrades like venting system or gas line are costly.
• The hot water output is split among all the household fixtures, resulting in inconsistent water temperature, temperature fluctuation or cold-water-sandwiches. This applies to economy type units.
• Venting gas and propane units require expensive stainless steel tubing, for some brands other materials are used.
• Electric instant water heaters may require an additional circuit and lots of energy.
• Gas water heaters require additional expenses of an annual servicing.
• Instant water heaters need a minimum flow rate to activate the heat exchanger.
• Tankless water heaters rely on the pressure that is delivered to your home - the reason why you need a good plumbing system.

Summary

As can be seen, there are many reasons why buying a tankless water heater is a good idea and long-term investment. To summarize; with the tankless, you can forget about running out of hot water, sediment build-up, bacteria build-up and rotten egg odor, discolored water, long recoveries, space issues for installation, energy waste, unnecessary energy use when hot water is not used, short life...

Related articles

Troubleshooting tankless water heaters
Comparing tankless
How to winterize tankless
Installing tankless
Compare prices

AO Smith error codes
Rheem error codes
Rinnai error codes
Noritz error codes
Takagi error codes
John Wood error codes

Baxi
Biasi
Vaillant